The trip ‘Round America covered 50 states and over 2,500 towns.
Bill Windsor is writing a book about the experience, and these are the pies (and other desserts) they’ve eaten.
The Best Pie in America | Special Pie Places | The Great Pie Adventure | Unusual Pies |
The Worst Pie in America | Methodology | Complete List of Pies and Rankings
We did use a system in rating the best and worst pies. Each pie was given a numerical rating between 1 and 100. We discussed each pie after eating. Then each night, we gave each pie a numerical rating by looking at previous ratings for the same type of pie as well as at the ratings for other pies that we felt the pie was comparable to in terms of overall “goodness.” We then assigned a numerical rating based upon how we felt the pie compared to others. We left space in the early rankings so we had plenty of room for great new pies to be ranked above the first pies we ate. Interestingly, the spread between the #1 pie and the #2 pie was just one point, but 95 days apart.
Rating food of any type is very subjective. All of our tastebuds and likes and dislikes are different. For example, I don’t like strawberries, so you won’t find any Strawberry Pie in our rankings, and we know there are some spectacular Strawberry Pies out there. To compensate for our prejudices, we tried many, many pies that we would not normally choose. We feel the system was good, though we would love to be able to taste the Top 12 side-by-side.
We recognize that we missed some great pie places and some great pies. That’s inevitable. We did ask many places what THEY felt was their best pie, and we usually tried that one.
We will do this again. We’ll use the same system. We will be awarding plaques and issuing news releases nationally as well as in the towns where we ate pie. We hope the publicity from this initial Best Pie in America effort will cause many folks to email us to tell us great places and great pies that should be included next time.
The Best Pie in America | Special Pie Places | The Great Pie Adventure | Unusual Pies | The Worst Pie in America | Methodology | Complete List of Pies and Rankings